When it comes to football’s biggest transfers, the debate always comes down to one thing: did the player justify the price tag? With fees soaring past £100m, expectations have never been higher. Using BBC Sport’s analysis, let’s break down the biggest deals—and what truly became of them. JACK GREALISH – £100m to Manchester City "Won it all at City, but never became the star £100m promised." GREALISH collected every major trophy at City but never rediscovered the electric consistency he had at Aston Villa. With limited contributions across two seasons and eventually being loaned to Everton, his

When it comes to football’s biggest transfers, the debate always comes down to one thing: did the player justify the price tag? With fees soaring past £100m, expectations have never been higher. Using BBC Sport’s analysis, let’s break down the biggest deals—and what truly became of them.

JACK GREALISH – £100m to Manchester City

"Won it all at City, but never became the star £100m promised."

GREALISH collected every major trophy at City but never rediscovered the electric consistency he had at Aston Villa. With limited contributions across two seasons and eventually being loaned to Everton, his time feels mixed at best. Verdict: Neither success nor failure somewhere in between.

DECLAN RICE – £100m to Arsenal

RICE has become world-class and the heartbeat of Arsenal’s midfield. Yet, he has only one piece of silverware the Community Shield. Arsenal’s title push will determine whether this investment proves worth it. Verdict: To be determined.

"Arsenal’s engine world-class, but still waiting for the trophies to match the price."

ROMELU LUKAKU – £97.5m to Chelsea

His return to Chelsea fizzled out fast. Despite a bright start, goals dried up and he left after one season. Verdict: Failure.

"£97.5m return, one season, no spark. A blockbuster that never exploded."

PAUL POGBA – £89m to Manchester United

Signed to transform United, POGBA never consistently delivered. Only one standout season and minimal team success. Left for free again. Verdict: Failure.

"£89m of unreal talent—delivered only in flashes, never consistently."

ANTONY – £82m to Manchester United

A shadow of the player he was at Ajax. Five Premier League goals in two seasons before departing. Ironically thriving at Betis. Verdict: Failure.

"Big fee, small impact. The magic from Ajax vanished at Old Trafford."

HARRY MAGUIRE – £80m to Manchester United

The world’s most expensive defender never matched expectations. Few trophies, inconsistent starts, and stripped of the captaincy. Verdict: Failure.

“The world’s most expensive defender… with nothing to show for it.”

JOSKO GVARDIOL – £77m to Manchester City

Strong start and still only 23, but fee feels heavy for now. Verdict: Jury still out.

“Bright future, heavy price. Too early to call—promise is there.”

ROMELU LUKAKU – £75m to Manchester United

Good goal numbers early on, but impact faded and United won nothing during his stay. Verdict: Failure, though fee was mostly recouped.

“Strong start, flat finish. Goals came early, trophies never did.”

VIRGIL VAN DIJK – £75m to Liverpool

The gold standard. Transformed Liverpool, lifted every major trophy, and defined an era. Verdict: Complete success.

“Elite. Dominant. Worth every penny. The standard for expensive signings.”

A little more informed. A little more connected.